14 U.S. Islands Now for Sale, Prices That Will Amaze You

Owning an island is a dream for many. If you want to invest in a US island, this list is for you. Find some of the cheapest islands for sale in the USA. We have also mentioned the price of renting them for a day so you can have a trial before making them yours.

Carolina Cays, North Carolina

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Craving a budget-friendly boating and fishing adventure?

This place is a heaven for budget friendly boating and fishing adventurers. For buyers, there are a total of 24 islands starting at $399,000. Sail around this chain of 24 islands for as little as $50 a night or even less at rustic campsites. Or splurge on a $2,000-a-week vacation rental for island luxury.

Campbell Island, New York

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Feeling fancy? Then, you can splurge on this 97-acre island in the New York area. The price is not disclosed.

For renters, this private Hudson River jewel can be all yours for a cool $10,000 a night. Rent the charming mansion and impress your guests with stunning river views and historical charm. Beware, there’s no bridge – arrive by boat!

Ormond-by-the-Sea, Florida

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Sunshine, surf, and history await on this barrier island. This 1 acre of island costs $500,000.

If you want vacations, budget $100 a night for a basic hotel room or treat yourself to a $500 oceanfront condo with balcony views. Don’t forget to climb the historic lighthouse for $5 and brag about the panoramic vista!

Little Raccoon Key, Georgia:

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Birdwatchers, listen up, this 40-acre paradise is full of feathered friends. For buyers, this piece of land is listed for $649,000, which is quite a steal deal.

You can also rent the only bungalow for $250 a night and spend your days exploring the private beach and spotting rare birds. Just remember, groceries are a boat ride away, so pack wisely.

Fantasy Guy Island, Minnesota:

St Anthony Main; Minneapolis, Minnesota: Third Avenue Bridge
Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Calling all “Survivor” fans. This 3-acre island named after the reality show is your Robinson Crusoe dream come true. It is priced at $669,000.

You can pitch a tent for $30 a night, fish for your dinner, and channel your inner island survivor (minus the million-dollar prize, unfortunately).

Bells Island, North Carolina:

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Bohemian vibes bloom on this 62-acre haven. Quirky artist studios and funky music venues line the streets. This island near North Carolina can be yours at just $695,000.

For renters, find cozy cottages for $150 a night or pitch a tent at the community campground for $20. Take advantage of the vibrant farmers’ market every Sunday.

Lookout Lake Island, Minnesota:

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Freshwater fun awaits on this 18-acre gem. It is priced only at $699,900.

Here, you can splash in the lake, cast a line for bass, or rent a kayak for $20 an hour. Rustic cabins here start at $100 a night, so you can rest them too. This island is perfect for a relaxing nature escape.

Starlings Island, Virginia

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Again, birders rejoice. This 75-acre island is home to over 200 feathered species. The price is to be disclosed upon request.

Here, you can book a cozy bed and breakfast for $120 a night and spend your days spotting warblers, owls, and maybe even a majestic bald eagle!

Horse Island (Massachusetts), Massachusetts

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Kayak through calm coves and paddleboard around hidden inlets on this 3-acre island. This island in Massachusetts is priced at $750,000.

Access is only by boat, so charter a ride for $75 or bring your vessel. Pack a picnic and spend the day soaking up the sun on secluded beaches.

Humphrey Island, Minnesota

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Chain of Lakes living awaits on this 17-acre island. Currently, it is priced at $975,000.

For trails, you can rent a pontoon boat for $50 an hour and cruise the sparkling waters or cast a line for walleye and perch. Rustic cabins start at $80 a night, perfect for a family fishing retreat.

Edenton Point, North Carolina

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

History buffs, unite. This 20-acre island shelters a Civil War-era fort. Although the price isn’t disclosed, if you want to own this piece of historic land, you have to have a budget of around a million.

Here, you can explore the ramparts for $5, then hike the nature trails and soak in the panoramic views. Budget-friendly campsites start at $20 a night, or you can splurge on a waterfront cottage for $250.

Island on Circle Lake, Minnesota

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Calling all boaters and anglers. This 100-acre island beckons with sparkling waters and abundant fish. Again, the price of this island is disclosed upon request, but you can have an estimation based on the acres and location.

To give it a shot, rent a motorboat for $40 an hour and zoom around the lake, or cast a line from the shore for crappie and bass. Cozy cabins start at $100 a night.

Captiva Key, Florida

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Seashell hunters, get ready, as this 13-acre island is a treasure trove of colorful shells. It is priced at $22000000.

For activities, you can relax on pristine beaches, rent a bike for $15 and explore the island’s hidden paths, or shop for unique souvenirs at charming boutiques. Book a beachfront condo for $300 a night and live the island life!

Little Hawkins Island, Georgia

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Nature lovers, this one’s for you. This 4-acre private reserve is a haven for hikers and birdwatchers. This little piece of heaven can be yours for just $ 15,900,000.

Explore the lush trails, spot migrating shorebirds, and unwind in the serene atmosphere. Guided tours start at $50, or rent kayaks for $20 an hour and paddle around the island’s secluded coves.

Scroll to Top